[AMRadio] A slight different approach to the IARU bandplan issue

SBJohnston at aol.com SBJohnston at aol.com
Thu Nov 15 00:03:03 EST 2007

Since I've been FAR from satisfied with the answers we're getting regarding 
the new Region 2 bandplan, I sent another message to ARRL and IARU Region 2 
officials today, repeating my concerns about the new bandplan and also taking a 
slightly different approach:  pointing out that the existing plan is far better 
than the new one.  Here's what I wrote, and the response I received from the 
President of the ARRL.   If you've been following this issue you should get a 
laugh out of it.  Guess what?  I'm ignorant and wrong again.

73  Steve WD8DAS

- - - - - - - - -

ARRL and IARU Officials -

I see that the IARU has adopted, effective January 1, 2008, a new 
voluntary band plan for Region 2 that would place restrictive 
limitations on transmitted signal bandwidths and overlooks 
commonly-used modes and practices on the bands 160 - 10m.

I am against such bandwidth and mode controls - tight regulation and 
restrictions like these goes completely against the experimental and 
innovative nature of ham radio.  The new Region 2 plan does not match 
common practice on the bands and would likely be ignored by thousands 
of operators.   What about AM operation?  How is bandwidth defined and 

Voluntary or not, my position is that we need no such plans restricting 
operation by bandwidth. Bandplans like this have a history of 
increasing the stress among amateurs with arguments and 
finger-pointing.   And without the details of how bandwidth is to be 
defined and measured, the figures in the bandplan are meaningless - 
except to cause fights among hams as they argue about them!

The existing IARU Region 2 bandplan is excellent - why the need for 
change to bandwidth specifications?

Thank you.

Steve Johnston, WD8DAS

- - - - - - - - -


Thank you for your email.

Your information is not correct. The IARU Region 2 band plan will not
restrict AM operators in any way and you will notice no change whatsoever to
your operating preference as a result of it.

ARRL has no regulatory petition pending, proposed or planned that would
limit or restrict AM phone operation in any way.

I have copied your ARRL Division Director, Dick Isely, W9GIG, on this email
so he will be aware of your comments as well.

73 Joel W5ZN

- - - - - - - - -


 See what's new at http://www.aol.com

More information about the AMRadio mailing list

This page last updated 18 Feb 2018.