[AMRadio] Open vs Closed -expanded

Todd, KA1KAQ ka1kaq at gmail.com
Fri Oct 30 11:16:54 EDT 2009

On Fri, Oct 30, 2009 at 3:07 AM, D. Chester <k4kyv at charter.net> wrote:

> Same here.  I have been hearing that a lot lately but it sounds awfully
> phoney to me.  Is this a carry-over from CB, like saying "personal" instead
> of "name"?

But since CB is a carry over from ham radio and was used pretty much
by hams for local communications (like the 2 meter band was initially)
even after it became CB, doesn't a lot of that really just carry back
to the amateur community? CBers used a lot of ham terms - Q signals,
73, 88 and so on, no doubt from that time. 'Contact' is certainly a
ham term, coming from those wonderful 'nets'.

For years CB and Incentive Licensing got the brunt of the blame for
all things bad in amateur radio by those wanting to make themselves
somehow look superior to others, until the no code techs came along.
Then the CW requirement was abolished and the codeless license became
the whipping post, at the expense of alienating new hams who had no
choice in what test they took. Lately it's the vanity call sign
program. It makes you wonder how these people can possibly enjoy
amateur radio if it makes them so miserable.

> I don't even like to use "break".  I just wait till I catch a pause between
> carriers and give my callsign.

And I've heard old timers rant on the air about how rude, stupid, etc
that is too. You don't just drop your callsign, that's rude! I also
remember old timers saying that you should never call CQ on the 75/80m
bands. It just wasn't 'proper'. Fortunately it was only a few, and
most folks seem to have not paid much attention to their rants. Newbie
or Old Timer, I suspect the idiot ratio remains fairly constant
regardless of age or time licensed.

Guess it's a good thing we get to decide for ourselves and don't have
to follow someone else's opinion of what's best and why. Amateur radio
is in enough trouble without having to weed out the 'unworthy' who
don't do things the way some think they should. Reminds me of the
masses railing against AM because they were better and smarter than
anyone using AM.

~ Todd,  KA1KAQ/4

More information about the AMRadio mailing list

This page last updated 15 Dec 2017.